Digital vs Analog: Why I Still Choose Paper in 2025
Me defending my archaic ways to a world that thinks everything should be an app
It's 2025. We have AI that can write essays, cars that drive themselves, and phones that can probably read our minds (they're definitely listening). So why am I still over here with my paper planner like it's 1995?
Great question. Let me explain while I refill my favorite fountain pen.
The Digital Temptation is Real
Don't get me wrong, I've tried it all. Notion databases that look like NASA mission control. Obsidian vaults with more connections than a conspiracy theorist's wall. Google Calendar with enough color coding to make a rainbow jealous.
I've downloaded every productivity app that's ever been featured on Product Hunt. I've watched YouTube tutorials on building the "ultimate digital planning system." I've spent hours creating templates that I used exactly once.
And you know what? They all left me feeling like something was missing.
The Tactile Connection
Here's what the digital productivity gurus don't tell you: there's something primal about putting pen to paper. It's the same reason (some) people still prefer physical books over e-readers, or why vinyl records made a comeback.
When I write something down by hand, I'm not just recording information, I'm creating a physical artifact of my thoughts. The pressure of the pen, the texture of the paper, the slight cramp in my hand after a long planning session: it all creates a multisensory experience that typing can't replicate.
Science backs this up too. Studies show that writing by hand activates different parts of your brain than typing, leading to better memory retention and idea generation. Your brain literally processes handwritten information differently.
The Focus Factor
My biggest issue with digital planning? The notifications. Even with focus modes and do-not-disturb settings, my phone is a gateway to infinite distraction. I open my digital planner to check my schedule and somehow end up watching TikToks about cats wearing hats.
Paper planners are gloriously offline. When I'm planning my week, I'm just... planning my week. No popup notifications about emails. No temptation to "quickly check" Instagram. Just me, my thoughts, and the therapeutic scratch of pen on paper.
The Customization Freedom
Digital tools promise infinite customization, but they always come with constraints. Someone else's idea of how a calendar should look. Pre-built templates that almost fit but not quite. Color schemes that work for everyone except you.
With paper, I can literally draw whatever makes sense for my brain. Need a space for tracking my water intake? I'll draw eight little circles. Want to track my mood with tiny weather icons? Why not. Need to doodle a stressed-out stick figure because Mercury is in retrograde again? The page is my oyster.
The Reliability Factor
Digital systems break. Apps get discontinued. Companies get bought and suddenly your perfectly organized system gets "upgraded" into something unrecognizable. Cloud storage fails. Phones die at the worst possible moments.
My paper planner has never needed a software update. It's never been down for maintenance. It doesn't require wifi or battery life or the latest iOS update. It just... works.
The Ritual of It All
There's something deeply satisfying about the physical ritual of planning. The sound of pages turning. The way my favorite pen feels in my hand. The decision of which color to use for which type of task.
These rituals create psychological boundaries between "planning time" and "everything else time." When I sit down with my planner, my brain knows it's time to focus. When I close it, the planning session is complete.
You can't replicate that ceremonial feeling with an app.
But Let's Be Real...
I'm not completely analog. I use digital tools for:
Shared calendars with my partner (because texting "did you remember we have dinner with your parents?" gets old)
Setting reminders for time-sensitive stuff
Storing reference information I might need on the go
Backup copies of important dates
The key is using digital tools to support my analog system, not replace it.
The Plot Twist
Here's what I've realized: choosing paper over digital isn't about being anti-technology. It's about being intentional about how technology fits into my life.
In a world where everything is optimized for engagement and designed to grab your attention, paper planning is an act of rebellion. It's choosing slowness over speed, depth over efficiency, mindfulness over multitasking.
My paper planner isn't just a productivity tool, it's a boundary. A way of saying "this time is mine, this space is mine, and I'm going to protect both."
The Bottom Line
Will paper planning work for everyone? Probably not. Some people thrive in digital systems, and that's totally fine. But if you've been struggling with digital overwhelm, if you find yourself constantly switching between apps, if you miss the satisfaction of physically crossing things off a list, maybe it's time to go analog (but I am probably preaching to the choir here).
In 2025, choosing paper might be the most radical productivity hack of all.
Are you team digital or team analog? Or are you a hybrid human like me? Let me know in the comments ☺️
Want more hot takes on productivity culture and behind-the-scenes looks at my very analog planning system? Subscribe for weekly posts that question everything the productivity industrial complex tells us.
Nice article. I use an iPad and a Safari note+ , though I love using my fountain pen gliding and pouring my thoughts on paper. My laptop for work, though I use my beloved typewriter for writings and reports. So, hybrid here leaning much on analog.